When it comes to full-time RV living, choosing the right setup can be a daunting task. With so many options available, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons of each to find the best fit for your lifestyle.
When we asked our readers what kind of RV do you own or prefer, the 2 winners were “Class A” with 41% and “Fifth Wheelers.” with 32% of the votes. So we wanted to delve into the age-old debate: Class A Motorhome vs. 5th Wheel Toy Hauler.
Both have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and what works for one person might not work for another. We found a great video that breaks down the key points of each option. Below, we’ve highlighted the main takeaways from the video, but be sure to watch the entire video at the bottom of the article for a more in-depth look.
1. Working from the RV
“Working from the RV in a place where we spend most of our time and that is at the workstation in our Class A Motorhome,” says the video host. The Class A Motorhome offers a dedicated workspace, but sharing that space can be challenging. “Many times if Daryl receives a call while I am on the phone or on a video call, he has to step outside to answer it so he doesn’t interrupt Michael.” On the other hand, the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler provides separate working areas, making it easier for both partners to work simultaneously without disturbing each other.
If only the RV came with a soundproof booth, we could avoid the “shush wars” during conference calls!
2. Livability
In terms of livability, the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler seems to have the upper hand. “Our fifth wheel had two bedrooms, one in the very front of the unit and the second in the garage,” the video explains. This setup offers more space and privacy for guests. The Class A Motorhome, however, typically has only one bedroom and a pull-out couch in the living room, which can make things a bit cramped when hosting visitors.
Who knew that hosting guests in an RV could turn into a game of Tetris with furniture?
3. Maneuverability
When it comes to maneuverability, the Class A Motorhome takes the cake. “For me, maneuvering the Class A is easier than the truck in the fifth wheel, especially in tight spaces,” the host mentions. The lack of a pivot point between the truck and the camper makes it easier to navigate through narrow roads and tight corners.
Navigating a 40-foot motorhome is like driving a giant marshmallow—soft and cushy, but surprisingly easy to handle!
4. Traveling Down the Highway
Traveling down the highway presents different experiences for each option. “While traveling in our Class A, we have access to our entire RV,” the video states. This makes it convenient to grab a snack or use the restroom without stopping. In contrast, the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler requires you to exit the truck to access the living area, which can be a hassle.
With a Class A, you can raid the fridge while on the move. Just don’t let the driver catch you stealing the last soda!
5. Storage
Storage is a significant factor for full-time RVers, and the Class A Motorhome excels in this area. “In our Class A, we have eight underneath storage compartments,” the host notes. This ample storage space is a game-changer for those who need to carry a lot of gear. The 5th Wheel Toy Hauler, while still offering decent storage, falls short in comparison.
With all that storage, you might finally have room for that inflatable unicorn pool float you’ve been eyeing!
6. Fuel Mileage
Fuel mileage is a crucial consideration for long-distance travelers. “Our Class A has a 150-gallon fuel tank and averages between seven and eight miles a gallon,” the video reveals. While the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler gets slightly better mileage, the larger fuel tank of the Class A reduces the number of fuel stops needed.
With fewer fuel stops, you’ll have more time to argue about who gets the last donut at the next gas station!
7. Hauling Toys
For those who love to bring along toys like motorcycles or kayaks, the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler is the clear winner. “The fifth wheel was called a toy hauler for a reason; it comes with a built-in garage,” the host explains. This dedicated space makes it easy to transport and store recreational equipment.
The 5th Wheel Toy Hauler is like a mobile garage sale—except you get to keep all the cool stuff!
8. Price Difference
Lastly, the price difference between the two options is significant. “The Class A is more than twice the investment than was the fifth wheel and the truck,” the video states. Maintenance costs for the Class A are also higher, making the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler a more budget-friendly option.
With the money you save on a 5th Wheel Toy Hauler, you could buy enough marshmallows to fill your new mobile garage!
In conclusion, both the Class A Motorhome and the 5th Wheel Toy Hauler have their pros and cons. Your choice will ultimately depend on your specific needs and preferences. For a more detailed comparison, make sure to watch the full video below. Happy RVing!
